When the paint won’t behave.
The twenty-two problems painters ask about most, why they happen, and what to do instead.
My mixes keep turning muddy
Every medium
Mud usually means too many pigments (more than three), or warm and cool versions fighting each other. Cap each pile at two or three paints, mix with a clean knife, and choose pigments biased toward the target: a cool yellow and a cool blue for clean greens. Remember that “mud” in one context is a beautiful grey in another: it’s only wrong if it doesn’t fit.
My tints look chalky
Oil, Acrylic, Gouache
Titanium white cools and dulls colour. Lighten with a lighter neighbour first (yellow for orange, for example), add only as much white as needed, or use zinc white or a touch of the colour’s warm neighbour to restore warmth.
Darks look dead and flat
Every medium
Black straight from the tube kills chroma. Mix chromatic darks instead: ultramarine + burnt sienna, phthalo green + alizarin, or dioxazine violet + a yellow-orange. They read as black but stay alive.
Acrylics dried a different colour
Acrylic
Wet acrylic binder is milky, so the colour you mix looks lighter than it will dry. Mix slightly lighter than your target and test on a scrap. In the studio here, switch Wet/Dry to preview the change.
Watercolour dried too pale
Watercolour
Watercolour dries lighter and duller, often by 10–30%. Mix stronger than you think, use more pigment and less water for darks, and judge only when dry.
Cauliflowers / blooms in washes
Watercolour
Water flowed back into a drying wash. Keep the water on your brush drier than the wash on the paper, or let it dry fully. Embrace blooms on purpose for skies and foliage.
Greens look artificial
Every medium
Tube greens (especially phthalo) are more intense than most foliage. Mix your own from yellow + blue, warm them with an earth or red, and vary them constantly across the painting.
Skin tones look grey or orange
Oil, Acrylic, Watercolour, Gouache
Start with an earth triad: yellow ochre, a red (vermilion or cadmium red light), and white, plus a cool (ultramarine or black) to neutralise. Warm the lights, cool the half-tones, and watch the temperature, not just the value.
Oil painting is cracking
Oil
Usually lean-over-fat: a fast-drying lean layer was painted over a slower, oilier one. Follow fat over lean, avoid excessive solvent, and let thick layers cure.
Dull patches in my oil painting
Oil
“Sinking in”: oil was absorbed by the layer beneath. Oil out with a thin film of medium wiped back before continuing, or varnish when the painting is fully cured.
Whites are turning yellow
Oil
Linseed oil yellows, especially in the dark. Use whites ground in safflower or poppy oil for the lightest passages, and hang paintings in light.
Pastel won’t stick anymore
Soft pastel
The tooth is full. Brush off excess, use a light spray of workable fixative to restore grip, or work on sanded paper, which takes many more layers.
Paper buckles under water
Watercolour, Gouache
Use 300 gsm (140 lb) or heavier paper, stretch it, or tape it to a board. Blocks (glued on four sides) stay flat.
Paint peeling off
Acrylic, Oil
Adhesion failure: acrylic over oil, painting on a greasy surface, or binder over-diluted with water on a non-absorbent ground. Use medium rather than water for very thin layers and paint on a properly primed surface.
Colours look different in daylight
Every medium
Light source matters: warm bulbs push everything yellow. Paint under neutral daylight-balanced lighting (about 5000–5500 K, high CRI) and check work in natural light.
My painting has no sense of light
Every medium
Light comes from contrast in value and temperature, not white paint. Group your values (squint), keep shadows and lights clearly separated, and choose a light temperature: warm light means cool shadows, and vice versa.
A colour is too strong and takes over
Every medium
High-tinting-strength pigments (phthalos, dioxazine, Prussian) dominate. Add them to the lighter colour, never the other way around, and in tiny amounts.
Can’t lift colour out of my watercolour
Watercolour
Staining pigments (phthalos, quinacridones, dioxazine) bind to the paper fibres. Use non-staining pigments (cobalt, ultramarine, earths) where you plan to lift.
Everything looks the same intensity
Every medium
Give the eye a hierarchy: keep most of the painting at moderate saturation and reserve your highest chroma for the focal area. Bright colours sing next to greys.
My mix matches the photo but looks wrong
Every medium
Photos crush shadows and shift colour. Squint at the subject, compare colours to their neighbours rather than in isolation, and adjust for the surrounding colours (simultaneous contrast).
Colours fade over time
Every medium
Choose ASTM lightfastness I or II paints. Fugitive pigments (genuine alizarin, some dye inks, cheap pinks) fade in sunlight. Check the pigment code on the tube.
Which paints are toxic?
Every medium
Cadmium, cobalt, lead (flake white), chromium and manganese pigments need care: don’t eat or drink while painting, don’t sand or spray them, and wash hands. Pastel dust should not be blown off; tap it into a damp cloth.